It's not surprising that Ellsbury has left. The vibe that Ellsbury would be looking for the best deal has been around the past couple of years. Boras as his agent only reinforced that. And for various reasons I laid out last November, I never really expected the Sox to pay out over $20M a year to keep him in Boston.
What I didn't expect was for the Yankees to be the team that signed him. If only because center field isn't a particular hole they need to fill. And that signing a 30-year-old position player to that long a deal is the kind of mistake they've already made.
To make this point, here are two players and their 2013 stats:
Player A: 134 Games Played | 172 H | 53 RBI | .781 OPS | 246 TB | 5.8 WAR | .992 Fielding Percentage | 347 Putouts
Player B: 145 Games Played | 147 H | 52 RBI | .759 OPS | 224 TB | 4.2 WAR | .991 Fielding Percentage | 327 Putouts
A is, of course, Jacoby Ellsbury. B is Yankees center-fielder Brett Gardner. Ellsbury is a better player...but not by much. And he isn't $17M+ better, which is the gap between the paycheck each man gets. Essentially, the Yankees just paid out over $150M for a player they already have.
Not exactly a smart long-term play, in my opinion. But to break down the Yankees' side of this I recommend reading Aviv's piece on it. Spoilers: he's sad.
But to look at this from the Boston perspective, let's look at Players A and B again:
Player A: .348 OBP | .774 OPS | 12 HRs
Player B: .329 OBP | .749 OPS | 15 HRs
2014 Bill James projections released last month for the Red Sox.
Now, is Bradley going to be the hitter that Ellsbury is? Not likely...at least not now considering JB is only 23 years old. But he is the fielder that Jacoby is right now...or even better. So what Boston has in center field right now is a player that gives them about 80% of Ellsbury at 2.5% of the cost. Read that again: 80% of Ellsbury at 2.5% of the cost.
Boston would have been stupid not to let Ellsbury move on at those numbers.
Baseball is not only about winning now - it's about being competitive year after year. That is a multi-faceted job. You have to keep your payroll down and flexible while maintaining a strong farm system. You have to extend key players while filling gaps with targeted free agents. And there are two thing you must not do.
- Sign aging free agents to expensive long-term deals
- Give your players excessive contracts based on past performance when you have adequate replacements for them
I'll miss Ellsbury. I was fortunate enough to watch him as he came through the farm system; he tore it up in Portland. He was lightning fast. I regret he won't break Harry Hooper's all-time steals record for Boston...maybe Jackie can take a run at it. And he was part of that wave of homegrown talent that transformed the Sox. Ellsbury, Youkilis, Pedroia, Lester, Buchholz, Papelbon...all of them have played a role in making Boston the best franchise in baseball right now.* And that shouldn't be pushed aside and forgotten simply because Ellsbury took a lot of money another team was stupid enough to offer to him.
It's a win/win deal. Ellsbury gets his money and the Sox get to see the Yankees continue their slow, downward spiral. Not too much wrong with that.
*Three WS rings in 10 years. Deal with it, haters.